No Bauer But Can Luca Cumani Still Win Melbourne Cup 2011?

October 30, 2011

No Bauer But Can Luca Cumani Still Win Melbourne Cup 2011?

After concerns earlier in the year that quarantine issues would force an international no-show in Flemington’s showcase race, the 2011 Melbourne Cup field now features a record 11 overseas raiders including two from the stables of high-profile European horseman Luca Cumani.

Originally hailing from Italy but now based at Newmarket in England, Cumani has prepared over 60 major winners across 10 countries throughout his prolific career as a trainer.

The Melbourne Cup, however, has eluded him.

The ever-dedicated Cumani has twice come close to preparing a Melbourne Cup winner having trained two runners-up in the time-honoured Flemington showdown.

His first Melbourne Cup second placegetter was Purple Moon who was defeated by the Lloyd Williams-owned Efficient in 2007.

Just 12 months later Cumani suffered a heartbreaking loss, popular grey galloper Bauer nudged out of the 2008 Melbourne Cup win by the Bart Cummings-trained Viewed who handed the Cups King his 12th victory by a nose.

Bauer was controversially scratched from the Melbourne Cup field last year in the eleventh hour due to fitness issues, and after looking on track for an incredible comeback this year, the now nine-year-old narrowly missed out on a start in the 2011 Cup having been balloted out by just one place.

Cumani now lays his hopes of a maiden Melbourne Cup victory in two horses, Drunken Sailor and Manighar.

Can one of Cumani’s two hopefuls finally break his Melbourne Cup hoodoo? Or will it be another case of ‘come back next year’ for the famed trainer.

#4 Drunken Sailor

  • Barrier: 8
  • Jockey: Dwayne Dunn
  • Weight: 54kg
  • Melbourne Cup Odds: $41 – Bet now at Luxbet
  • Pros: Drunken Sailor has fair form in England having won the Goodwood Stakes back in July, and their seventh in the Caulfield Cup last start was better than it looks on paper. They have the right weight to be competitive dropping 2.5kg from Caulfield and meeting the favourite 4kg better. Keen for a good showing having missed the race last year when 11th in the Geelong Cup, has run second over 3218m in Britain so distance is a non-issue and local jockey Dunn helps their cause.
  • Cons: Faces other European raiders that have beaten them before and can do so again, gets blinkers but may not be enough to sharpen them for this big test. Queries after a poor effort in trackwork last week.
  • Verdict: Cumani is desperate and wouldn’t have accepted this horse if they didn’t stand some chance, include them in Melbourne Cup First Four selections at Luxbet for value.

#6 Manighar

  • Barrier: 21
  • Jockey: Damien Oliver
  • Weight: 54kg
  • Melbourne Cup Odds: $31  – Bet now at Luxbet
  • Pros: Oliver is the jockey you want in the saddle after their Derby Day triple, nicely weighted too with 54kg. Has experience in the Melbourne Cup having run seventh last year from barrier 19. Comes off a last-start fourth in the Caulfield Cup, one better than their Caulfield Cup 5th from 12 months ago so look fit and improved. Very consistent and honest horse
  • Cons: Yet to win in Australia and nasty barrier 21 won’t help their cause, is always thereabouts but that doesn’t win Melbourne Cups.
  • Verdict: Won’t win but could finish in the placings with some luck and a good ride so take them in the Melbourne Cup Trifecta at Luxbet.

The $6 million Group 1 Emirates Melbourne Cup (3200m) runs as Flemington Race 7 at 3:00pm (local time) on Tuesday November 1, 2011.

To view the Melbourne Cup field and betting odds, head to the Tabcorp-owned and trusted bookmaker Luxbet now.

Luxbet have the best range of Melbourne Cup wagers and offers including our favourite – a $500 Bonus Bet for new customers that deposit and quote the codeword BONUSBET.

Racing fields and data are copyright 2011-2018 © Racing Australia Pty Ltd (RA) (and other parties working with it).
Racing materials, including fields, form and results, is subject to copyright which is owned by RA and other parties working with it. Full copyright notice.

Spring Racing

Rogerson Dreams of 2018 Melbou...

The Everest 2018 Field to Feat...

The Everest 2018 Field to Feature Redzel

Inaugural champion Redzel has officially secured his position in the 2018 The...

2018 The Everest Field Takes S...

2018 The Everest Field Takes Shape: In Her Time Confirmed

She missed out on a shot at the world’s richest race on turf last spring but...

Trapeze Artist Secures 2018 Th...

Trapeze Artist Secures 2018 The Everest Slot for Aquis

The first official slot in The Everest 2018 field has been confirmed with...

El Dorado Dreaming of 2018 VRC...

El Dorado Dreaming of 2018 VRC Oaks Bid

Ben Smith’s ATC Sires’ Produce Stakes winning filly El Dorado Dreaming is in...

Horse Racing Today

BRC Sires’ Produce Stake...

Waller contemplating blinkers ...

Waller contemplating blinkers for 2018 Queensland Oaks favourite Youngstar

Trainer Chris Waller will decide before final acceptance time on Wednesday...

Waller to have multiple runner...

Waller to have multiple runners in 2018 Queensland Oaks

Recently inducted Hall Of Fame trainer Chris Waller is likely to have multiple...

McDonald to team up with Care ...

McDonald to team up with Care To Think in the 2018 Kingsford-Smith Cup

James McDonald will be hoping for a quick return to the Group 1 winner’s stall...

2018 Doomben Cup winner Comin&...

2018 Doomben Cup winner Comin’ Through beats stablemate Egg Tart

The Chris Waller trained Comin’ Through claimed his first Group 1 victory when...

Race Results

Viewed Victorious in Caulfield Cup

Race 1 Result – $101 500 AGL Renewable Energy Stakes – She’s Got Gears Wins

Race 2 – $101,500 Schiavello Plate – Avienus Wins

Race 3 – $101 500 Lavazza A Modo Mio – Linton Street Wins

Race 4 Results – $151,500 Listed Herald Sun Stakes – Strawberry Field Wins

Race Previews

2009 Caulfield Cup Barrier Draw Announced

Who Are the Top Contenders for Tomorrow’s Caulfield Cup?

Victoria Derby in sight for Onemorenomore

2009 Melbourne Cup Field

Eclipse Stakes Final Field & Preview

Fields & Form

Can Kelinni Win Sydney Cup 2013 for the Punters?

Moroney Gets into Queensland Derby 2013 Rhythm

Buffering Draws 7 – 2013 BTC Cup Final Field and Barrier Draw

SA Fillies Classic 2013 Field Released

13 two-year-olds in 2013 Champagne Classic Field